Red Devils’ Penalty Shootout Defeat to League Two Side Exposes Amorim’s Tactical Flaws and Squad Fragility
The Carabao Cup has delivered its share of upsets over the years, but few will sting like Manchester United’s exit to Grimsby Town. On a night that should have been a straightforward progression for a club of United’s stature, Rúben Amorim’s side crashed out in dramatic fashion: a 2-2 draw followed by a 12-11 penalty shootout loss to a League Two team. It’s the kind of result that doesn’t just hurt—it haunts. For Amorim, already under the microscope after a dismal start to the season, this could be the moment where the cracks in his project become chasms.
Grimsby, a side from England’s fourth tier, had no business troubling United. Yet, they led 2-0 at halftime, capitalizing on a disorganized defense that has become all too familiar under Amorim. The Mariners’ goals came from set pieces and quick counters, exposing the vulnerabilities in United’s 3-4-3 system—a formation the Portuguese coach has stubbornly clung to despite mounting evidence it doesn’t suit his squad. A near-third goal for Grimsby was ruled out for offside, but the damage was done. United’s players looked shell-shocked, their high-priced talent reduced to chasing shadows against part-timers.
The comeback, when it came, felt more like a desperate scramble than a show of strength. Bryan Mbeumo and Harry Maguire pulled United level late in the game, forcing extra time. But even then, the cracks showed: Benjamin Šeško, the £74 million summer signing, blazed over from six yards with the last kick of the match. The penalty shootout was a farce—misses from Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha underscoring the fragility of a team that spent over £200 million on forwards yet can’t convert when it matters. Grimsby’s victory marked the first time United had lost to a fourth-tier side in this competition, shattering a perfect 11-0 record against such opponents.
Amorim’s post-match comments were cryptic and telling. “My players spoke loud for me,” he said, hinting at a disconnect between his vision and their execution. He pointed to the goal as the turning point, where United “forgot how to play,” shifting to a defensive mindset that invited pressure. It’s a recurring theme: the 3-4-3 leaves midfield exposed, with Manuel Ugarte and Kobbie Mainoo unable to control games. The defense, including Diogo Dalot and Tyler Fredricson, has been leaky, and goalkeeper André Onana’s handling of corners remains questionable. Up front, the new signings are yet to gel, starved of service in a system that favors inverted wingers over direct supply.
This isn’t just one bad night—it’s a symptom of deeper issues. Amorim inherited a dysfunctional squad from Erik ten Hag last November, but after 45 games, his 19 defeats outnumber his 17 wins, giving him the worst record of any United manager since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. The season’s start—a 1-0 loss to Arsenal and a 1-1 draw with Fulham—has piled on the pressure. Fans chanted “You’re getting sacked in the morning” at Grimsby, a low point that echoes the club’s post-Ferguson struggles. Yet, United’s hierarchy remains committed to Amorim, wary of another managerial merry-go-round.
The summer window, closing on September 1, offers a slim chance for fixes. United need midfield energy, defensive solidity, and attacking depth, but with the likes of Cunha and Šeško underperforming, solutions feel distant. Amorim’s refusal to adapt his system—despite calls for a more balanced 4-3-3—risks further alienation. Grimsby exposed not just tactical flaws but a mental fragility: the team collapsed under pressure, much like last season’s Europa League final loss to Tottenham.
For Amorim, this could be a line in the sand. United can’t afford more humiliations, especially with a tough league schedule ahead. If Grimsby isn’t the wake-up call, what will be? The club’s history demands better, but right now, the path back to glory looks longer than ever. As Amorim himself said, “We’re in a moment when people will pay attention to everything.” All eyes are on him to turn the tide—or face the consequences.
Follow us @Sportscliffs on Twitter and Instagram and also like our facebook page
